The Rubber Band Effect: Unwrapping CVT Transmission Issues

NaTasha Brand • October 1, 2025

Smooth operator or rubber-band nightmare

There’s a good chance your newer sedan, SUV, or even truck doesn’t shift gears. Instead of the familiar climb through first, second, and third, the engine note just rises and falls like a singer holding a single, seamless note. Welcome to the world of the Continuously Variable Transmission, or CVT.

Loved by manufacturers for fuel efficiency and hated by some enthusiasts for its unusual feel, the CVT is a different beast altogether. And here in San Angelo, where a drive to Midland feels like a cross-country expedition, understanding its quirks and common failures is key to avoiding a costly roadside moment. Let’s pop the hood on this modern marvel and its common ailments.

How a CVT Works (Without the Boring Engineering Textbook Stuff)
Forget what you know about gears. A traditional automatic has a set number of fixed gear ratios (usually 6 to 10). A CVT is, in theory, infinitely variable. Most use a brilliant yet simple system: two pulleys connected by a stout metal push belt or chain.

One pulley connects to the engine, the other to the wheels. As you accelerate, the pulleys change their width, which changes their effective diameter, seamlessly adjusting the "gear ratio" for optimal power or efficiency. It’s like having a single, magical gear that can morph into any size needed. Hence the feeling of the engine "rubber-banding" – it finds the optimal RPM and stays there while the car accelerates.

Common CVT Failures: When the Magic Fades
While clever, this system has its Achilles' heels. Here are the most common CVT problems we see at Ric Henry’s Auto Service:

The Dreaded Overheating
The single biggest killer of CVTs is heat. The constant friction between the belt and pulleys generates significant heat, especially under San Angelo’s brutal summer sun, when towing, or in stop-and-go traffic. Excessive heat breaks down the specialized transmission fluid, which leads to…

Symptom: A burning smell, warning lights on the dash (often a flashing "D" or check engine light), and ultimately, shuddering or loss of drive.

Belt or Chain Slippage and Jerking
The push belt or chain is the heart of the system. Over time, it can wear, stretch, or even snap. When it slips, it feels exactly like a slipping clutch in a manual car: the engine RPMs flare up without a corresponding increase in speed.

Symptom: A jerking sensation, a noticeable "shudder" during acceleration, or a high-revving engine that doesn't translate to going faster.

The Whine of Doom
A certain amount of whirring or whining is normal for a CVT. But when a normal whine escalates to a loud, angry whine or grinding noise that gets worse with acceleration, it’s a major red flag. This often points to bearing failure or severe wear inside the pulleys.

Symptom: A loud, persistent whining that increases with vehicle speed.

Software Gremlins
The CVT is entirely computer-controlled. Bugs, glitches, or outdated software can cause all sorts of erratic behavior, from delayed engagement when you shift from Park to Drive to harsh, simulated "shift points" that feel like jolts.

Symptom: Erratic shifting, the car hesitating before moving, or going into a "limp mode" that limits speed.

How to Prevent a CVT Catastrophe: Be Smarter Than the Transmission
You can’t make a CVT bulletproof, but you can dramatically extend its life with smart habits.
  • Fluid is Everything: This is non-negotiable. CVT fluid is a specialized fluid, different from regular ATF. Follow your manufacturer’s severe service maintenance schedule (which applies to most San Angelo drivers due to our heat and dust). A fluid flush every 60,000 miles is cheap insurance against a $6,000 replacement.
  • Avoid Jackrabbit Starts: CVTs hate abrupt, heavy throttle. Smooth, gradual acceleration is your friend. It reduces heat and wear on the belt and pulleys.
  • No Towing (Unless It's Explicitly Rated for It): If your vehicle isn't rated for towing, don't hook up a trailer. The constant strain is a death sentence for many CVTs.
  • Let it Warm Up: On a cold morning, give the car 30-60 seconds to circulate fluid before driving off. This is especially important for CVT longevity.

Why CVT Repair is a Job for Ric Henry’s Auto Service
A CVT is not a transmission you can fix in your driveway with a basic toolset. It requires:
  • Specialized Knowledge: Understanding the complex hydraulic and electronic controls.
  • Proprietary Tools: Specific scanners to diagnose computer issues and special tools for assembly.
  • The Right Fluid: Using the wrong fluid will destroy the transmission in short order.
At Ric Henry’s Auto Service, our technicians are trained on these modern systems. We use the correct fluids, advanced diagnostics, and the same tools you’d find at the dealership to accurately diagnose and service your CVT, whether it needs a fluid service or a more complex repair. And every service is backed by our 3-Year/36,000-Mile Warranty.

The Rubber Band Effect: Unwrapping CVT Transmission Issues
By NaTasha Brand October 8, 2025
Is your engine shaking? Learn what a misfire is, its common causes, and why ignoring it can lead to costly damage. Trust San Angelo's Ric Henry's Auto Service for expert diagnosis & repair backed by a 3-year warranty.
By NaTasha Brand October 7, 2025
Is your car's water pump on its last legs? Learn the tell-tale signs of a failing water pump, why it's the heart of your cooling system, and why San Angelo drivers trust Ric Henry's Auto Service for expert diagnosis and repair. Don't let a small leak leave you stranded!
By NaTasha Brand October 6, 2025
You're sitting at a red light in San Angelo, the AC is battling the West Texas heat, and you hear it: a persistent, rapid tick-tick-tick-tick coming from under the hood. It’s not loud enough to be a knock, but it’s too rhythmic to ignore. Welcome to the world of "lifter tick," one of the most common, and often misunderstood, engine noises. Before you panic and imagine your car’s engine scattering itself across US-87, take a deep breath. At Ric Henry's Auto Service, we’ve diagnosed countless cases of lifter tick. Sometimes it’s a simple fix; other times, it’s a warning sign of a more serious issue. Let’s pop the hood and demystify this annoying clickety-clack. What Do Lifters Do, Anyway? To understand the tick, you need to know the lifter's job. Think of your engine’s valvetrain as a complex puppet show. The camshaft is the puppeteer, and it uses lifters (also called tappets) as its hands to control the valves. The valves are the gates that let air and fuel in and exhaust out of the engine's cylinders. The lifters are the critical middlemen that sit between the camshaft and the valves. They translate the rotating motion of the camshaft into the up-and-down motion that opens and closes the valves with precise timing. In modern vehicles, you often have hydraulic lifters. These are clever, self-admitting devices filled with oil. The oil pressure inside them automatically takes up the slack between the camshaft and the valve, ensuring everything operates smoothly and quietly, even as components heat up and expand. So, What is Lifter Tick? Lifter tick is the sound of that precision system failing to operate silently. It occurs when there’s excess clearance between the lifter and the valve—a gap that shouldn't be there. The most common cause is when a hydraulic lifter fails to pressurize properly with oil. Instead of a smooth, cushioned push, you get a tiny, metallic "slap" each time the camshaft lobe hits the lifter. That "slap" is the ticking sound you hear, and it happens thousands of times per minute. Should You Be Concerned? Symptoms and Severity The big question: is this a "get it fixed now" problem or an "I'll get to it eventually" issue? The answer depends on the symptoms. The "Maybe Not an Emergency" Tick: The Sound: A light, consistent tick that is most audible at idle and may quiet down or disappear as you increase engine RPM. The Cause: Often low oil level, old/thin oil, or a single lifter "sticking" slightly. The San Angelo heat can thin out oil over time, exacerbating this. The "You Should Be Concerned" Tick: The Sound: A loud, persistent ticking that doesn't go away, gets louder with acceleration, or is accompanied by a loss of engine power. The Symptoms: Loss of Power & Poor Fuel Economy: A collapsed lifter isn't opening a valve fully, robbing that cylinder of power. Check Engine Light: The engine's computer detects misfires or inefficiency. Engine Misfire: You may feel the engine shuddering or stumbling, especially at idle. Metallic Debris in Oil: In a worst-case scenario, a failing lifter can begin to disintegrate, sending metal shavings throughout your engine's oil system. Ignoring a serious tick can lead to a domino effect of damage. A lifter that isn't opening a valve properly can cause that valve to overheat. That worn lifter can also score the camshaft lobe. What starts as a few hundred-dollar repair can quickly escalate into a multi-thousand-dollar valvetrain overhaul or even engine damage. Why a Professional Diagnosis is Non-Negotiable You might be tempted to try a "mechanic in a can" oil additive. While sometimes effective for a mild, sticky lifter, these are merely masking agents, not a cure. Diagnosing the exact cause requires a professional ear and professional tools. Accurate Diagnosis: Is it a lifter? A cracked exhaust manifold? A failing timing chain tensioner? These can sound similar to an untrained ear. Our technicians at Ric Henry's Auto Service use the same advanced tools and equipment that dealerships use, like mechanical stethoscopes and borescopes, to pinpoint the exact source of the noise. The Right Repair: Replacing lifters is a complex, labor-intensive job that often requires removing the cylinder heads. It demands precision, proper torque specs, and the right parts. The Ric Henry's Warranty: When we repair your engine's valvetrain, you don't just get peace and quiet—you get peace of mind. Every repair is backed by our 3-year/36,000-mile nationwide warranty. Don't just listen to the tick. Understand it. A timely diagnosis is the difference between a simple service and a catastrophic repair bill. Bring your ticking engine to Ric Henry's Auto Service. Let our experts quiet things down. After all, the only thing that should be ticking in San Angelo is the clock on the wall, not the engine in your car.
More Posts →